Studying medullary thymic epithelial cells in vitro has been largely unsuccessful, as current 2D culture systems do not mimic the in vivo scenario. The 3D culture system described herein – a modified skin organotypic culture model – has proven superior in recapitulating mTEC proliferation, differentiation and maintenance of promiscuous gene expression.
Intra-thymic T cell development requires an intricate three-dimensional meshwork composed of various stromal cells, i.e., non-T cells. Thymocytes traverse this scaffold in a highly coordinated temporal and spatial order while sequentially passing obligatory check points, i.e., T cell lineage commitment, followed by T cell receptor repertoire generation and selection prior to their export into the periphery. The two major resident cell types forming this scaffold are cortical (cTECs) and medullary thymic epithelial cells (mTECs). A key feature of mTECs is the so-called promiscuous expression of numerous tissue-restricted antigens. These tissue-restricted antigens are presented to immature thymocytes directly or indirectly by mTECs or thymic dendritic cells, respectively resulting in self-tolerance.
Suitable in vitro models emulating the developmental pathways and functions of cTECs and mTECs are currently lacking. This lack of adequate experimental models has for instance hampered the analysis of promiscuous gene expression, which is still poorly understood at the cellular and molecular level. We adapted a 3D organotypic co-culture model to culture ex vivo isolated mTECs. This model was originally devised to cultivate keratinocytes in such a way as to generate a skin equivalent in vitro. The 3D model preserved key functional features of mTEC biology: (i) proliferation and terminal differentiation of CD80lo, Aire-negative into CD80hi, Aire-positive mTECs, (ii) responsiveness to RANKL, and (iii) sustained expression of FoxN1, Aire and tissue-restricted genes in CD80hi mTECs.
Developing thymocytes make up about 98 % of the thymus, while the remaining 2 % consists of a variety of cells that collectively compose the thymic stroma (i.e., epithelial cells, dendritic cells, macrophages, B cells, fibroblasts, endothelial cells). The outer cortical epithelial cells (cTECs) procure immigration of pro-T cells from the bone marrow, T cell lineage induction in multipotent pre-T cells and positive selection of self-MHC restricted immature thymocytes. The inner medullary thymic epithelial cells (mTECs) are involved in tolerance induction of those thymocytes with a high-affinity TCR for self-peptide/MHC complexes by either inducing negative selection or their deviation into the T regulatory cell lineage. In the context of central tolerance induction, mTECs are unique in that they express a wide spectrum of tissue-restricted self-antigens (TRAs) thus mirroring the peripheral self. This phenomenon is called promiscuous gene expression (pGE)1,2.
Most current studies on this fascinating cell type rely on ex vivo isolated cells, as various short-term 2D culture systems invariably resulted in the loss of pGE and key regulator molecules like MHC class II, FoxN1 and Aire within the first 2 days3-6. It remained however unclear, which particular components and features of the intact 3D meshwork of the thymus were missing in 2D models. The re-aggregation thymic organ culture (RTOC) has been so far the only 3D system that allows the study of T cell development, on the one hand, and stromal cell biology, on the other hand, in an intact thymic microenvironment7. Yet, RTOCs have certain limitations, i.e., they already contain a complex mixture of cells, require the input of fetal stromal cells and endure a maximal culture period of 5 to 10 days.
The lack of reductionist in vitro culture systems has hampered the study of several aspects of T cell development and thymic organogenesis not least the molecular regulation of pGE and its relationship to the developmental biology of mTECs.
Owing to the close-relatedness of the structured organization of the epithelial cells of skin and thymus, we opted for a 3D organotypic culture (OTC) system that had been developed originally to emulate the differentiation of keratinocytes in vitro and thus create a dermal equivalent. The OTC system consists of an inert scaffold matrix overlaid with dermal fibroblasts that are trapped in a fibrin gel, onto which keratinocytes are seeded8,9. Here, we replaced keratinocytes with purified mTECs. While keeping the basic features of this model, we optimized certain parameters.
In the adopted OTC model mTECs proliferated, underwent terminal differentiation and maintained mTEC identity and pGE, thus closely mimicking in vivo mTECs development10. This technical note provides a detailed protocol allowing the stepwise set-up of thymus OTCs.
This study has been approved by the ethics committee of the Regierungspräsidium Karlsruhe. All animals were housed under specific pathogen-free conditions at the German Cancer Research Center (DKFZ). For all culture experiments mouse pups ranging from 1 to 7 days of age were used.
1. Isolation of mTECs from Thymus
NOTE: The following digestion steps were performed as described previously1 under sterile conditions with some modifications as follows.
2. 3D Organotypic Co-cultures (OTCs)
NOTE: The 3D-dermal constructs for organotypic cultivation of keratinocytes were prepared as described previously9,13. At all steps cells were incubated at 37 °C and 5% CO2. The OTCs using mTECs were prepared with slight modifications as follows.
We adopted a 3D organotypic co-culture model (3D OTC) which had been originally developed for in vitro long term culture of keratinocytes9. MACS-enriched mTECs (see MACS enrichment scheme Figure 1) were seeded onto a scaffold comprising of a fibrin gel and entrapped fibroblasts. The fibroblasts provide the essential extracellular matrix (ECM) supporting mTECs in vitro. MTECs were cultivated in OTCs for 4-14 days in the presence of RANKL in submerged cultures unlike keratinocytes, which are air-exposed mimicking their in vivo environment (see OTC set-up scheme Figure 2).
Both mTEC subsets analyzed here (i.e., CD80lo and CD80hi mTECs) survived during the entire culture period of up to 14 days. MTECs were identified by keratin 14 expression and were easily distinguishable from vimentin-positive fibroblasts (Figure 3A, 3B). Interestingly, immature and mature mTECs grew in different patterns in culture. The CD80lo mTECs typically formed bi-layers (in close contact with fibroblasts), while CD80hi mTECs tended to form compact cell aggregates delimited by fibroblasts. These patterns were highly reproducible.
The mTEC subsets not only survived but also proliferated under 3D OTC conditions as assessed by EdU incorporation (Figure 3C, 3D). Interestingly, the CD80lo mTECs proliferated at a higher rate in the presence of RANKL, while the reverse was true for CD80hi mTECs10.
Additionally, CD80lo mTECs differentiated into CD80hi mTECs in the presence of RANKL within 4 days of culture, as indicated by the strong up-regulation of CD80. The differentiated mTECs also maintained the expression of Aire, FoxN1 (gene and protein) as well as promiscuously expressed Aire-independent and -dependent TRAs10.
Figure 1. MACS enrichment of TECs. After filtering, mTECs were enriched from the thymus single cell suspension using magnetic cell sorting (MACS). First, the hematopoietic cell lineages were depleted using anti-CD45 Microbeads. The CD45– cells were then incubated with anti-CD80 PE antibody, followed by anti-PE Microbeads. The eluate containing CD80+ -mature mTECs was directly cultured on the OTCs, while the flow-through contained CD80– immature mTECs and other stromal cells. MTECs were further enriched using anti-EpCAM-bio antibody and streptavidin Microbeads. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 2. Scheme for the stepwise setup of the 3D OTCs. A scaffold matrix was placed into a 12-well filter insert. The dermal fibroblasts from explanted skin (270,000 cells/OTC well) were inoculated into a fibrin gel (consisting of 1:1 ratio of fibrinogen and thrombin). These dermal equivalents were sustained for 4-5 days with DMEM + nutrients until mTECs (250,000 cells/OTC well) were seeded on top and cultured with medium enriched with different nutrient (rFAD + nutrients).
Figure 3. Growth patterns and proliferation of mTECs within the OTCs. The enriched CD80lo mTECs tend to grow as a bi-layer in close contact with the fibroblasts (A), whereas the differentiated CD80hi mTECs grow as cell aggregates or tight clusters (B). OTCs were labeled on day 4 of culture with anti-keratin 14 (red) and anti-vimentin antibodies (green) along with nuclear staining (Hoechst, blue). To evaluate the proliferation of mTECs, the OTCs were pulsed with EdU (6.7 µM/ml, i.e., 10 µM/well) for 4 hr prior to termination of the cultures. The OTC cryo-sections were then stained with anti-keratin 14 (green), and EdU-Click-iT reaction mixture (magenta) along with nuclear staining (Hoechst, blue). Representative images depicting proliferating EdU+ CD80lo mTECs (C) and EdU+ CD80hi mTECs (D) are shown. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Reaggregation thymic organ cultures (RTOC) | Organotypic co-cultures (OTC) |
Useful system to study cellular interactions that can be readily monitored and manipulated using a largely intact 3D thymic architecture; develops into a properly organized structure upon grafting. | Useful system to study development and differentiation of enriched/purified thymic epithelial cells in an artificial 3D meshwork generated by human skin fibroblasts entrapped in a fibrin scaffold. |
Well established for the study of the development of thymic epithelial cells and thymocytes using inhibitors or modifiers, which penetrate the capsule. | Amenable to manipulate thymus epithelial development or to study thymocyte development in co-culture with TECs. |
Since the system is air-lifted, the membrane pore size (0.8 µm) is crucial when supplying factors to the RTOC: larger molecules may not penetrate through the membrane and/or capsule. | Culture is submerged in media, which facilitates uptake of substances/factors (successfully tested using morpholino oligos). |
Adult and post-natal TECs or thymocytes can be spiked into fetal RTOCs. | Post-natal TECs grow better than adult TECs; fetal TECs not yet tested. |
Require embryonic E14-14.5 thymi (optimal) to allow for reaggregation and integration of the added desired population; difficult to control the fetal thymic (acceptor) cell composition; RTOCs require cells from either fluorescently labelled or congenic mice as donor or acceptor cells. | Possible to study single cells/clones; only “contaminants” are human skin fibroblasts required to provide ECM to support the TECs. |
Imaging limited to penetration depth of live two-photon microscopy; amenable to FACS analysis or sorting; gene expression studies require FACS sorting of the desired cell type after culture. | Fully accessible to imaging; suitable for FACS analysis, immuno-histochemistry, and gene expression studies. |
Table 1. Comparison between two 3D thymic culture systems.
Alongside RTOCs, the 3D OTCs have been by far superior in terms of TEC differentiation and pGE maintenance/induction (Table 1) compared to other (i) ‘simplified 3D cultures’ using – fibroblasts alone without the scaffold; (ii) 2D systems using – fibroblasts/feeder cells co-cultured with TECs10, (iii) 3T3-J2 cells wherein TEC clones develop, but pGE is lost, (iv) matrigel or (v) ECM components (unpublished data). PGE was maintained for up to 7 days in the 3D OTCs, 4 days being the optimum time-point thereafter, pGE starts to decline. Other morphological TEC features were maintained for up to 14 days. Intriguingly, the OTCs supported the end-stage of mTEC differentiation seen by the occasionally formed Hassall-like structures10.
The thymi used for OTCs were derived from young post-natal mice as they have a higher propensity to survive in culture compared to adult thymi. TECs derived from embryonic thymi have not yet been tested in OTCs. More so, after the long digestion period (not using trypsin due to cleavage of certain epitopes) the cells appeared more viable using MACS rather than FACS sorting cells. Using a two-step positive enrichment protocol on MACS columns (anti-PE beads) of CD80+ mTECs additionally improved TEC purity.
For the OTC setup it is essential to make sure that the viscose, nonwoven fibrous material is cut into sharp, well demarcated circles without loose fragments or serrated ends as stated above that exactly fit into 12 well-culture inserts. Alternatively, scaffolds such as BEMCOT- viscose wiper M-3 (http://www.bemliese.com) can also be used. The well size for the OTC is also critical and should be tested, if plate formats other than 6-well and 12-well formats should be used.
The fibrin gel should be prepared such that the fibrinogen and thrombin components do not come into contact with each other before being set onto the OTC, make sure to exchange the pipette tip. Mix the two components thoroughly in the plate over the scaffold to form a smooth upper surface. Always prepare a test gel alongside in a well without scaffold to check for proper clot formation and to have a good estimate of the time required for clotting. Make sure that the fibrin gel in the OTC has completely clotted before supplying the cultures with media.
Upon termination of the cultures the seeded mTECs can be easily retrieved by enzymatic digestion (collagenase/dispase) of the fibrin gel, which can be used for characterization of cultured mTECs e.g., by flow cytometry or PCR.
The 3D OTCs described herein has the potential to study or manipulate several TEC parameters namely: 1) to study and/or manipulate (via siRNA, morpholino oligos) developmental pathways and functions of mTECs; 2) to study the role of mTECs in T cell development; 3) to culture cTECs; 4) to test the progenitor potential of thymic derived stem cells; 5) to culture human TECs and stem cells; 6) to perform single TEC clonal assays. The 3D OTCs represent an elaborate culture technique emulating part of the in vivo thymus microenvironment. It should be emphasized that any additional assays applied to TECs in the current OTC setup will need to be thoroughly tested and optimized separately.
The authors have nothing to disclose.
This work has been supported by the German Cancer Research Center (DKFZ), the EU-consortium “Tolerage”, the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft (SFB 938) and the Landesstiftung Baden-Württemberg.
Pregnant C57BL/6 mice | Charles River WIGA | ||
LS columns | Miltenyi Biotec | 130-042-401 | |
MS columns | Miltenyi Biotec | 130-042-201 | |
CD45 Microbeads, mouse | Miltenyi Biotec | 130-052-301 | |
Anti-PE Microbeads | Miltenyi Biotec | 130-048-801 | |
Streptavidin Microbeads | Miltenyi Biotec | 130-048-101 | |
EpCAM (G8.8 -Alexa 647 and -biotin) | Ref. 12 | ||
CD80-PE antibody | BD Pharmingen | 553769 | |
CD45-PerCP antibody | BD Pharmingen | 557235 | |
Ly51-FITC antibody | BD Pharmingen | 553160 | |
CDR1-Pacific Blue | Ref. 15 | ||
Keratin 14 antibody | Covance | PRB-155P | |
Vimentin antibody | Progen | GP58 | |
Cy3-conjugated AffiniPure Goat anti-Rabbit IgG (H+L) | Jackson ImmunoResearch | 111-165-003 | |
Alexa 488-conjugated AffiniPure F(ab')2 Fragment Goat anti-Guinea Pig IgG (H+L) | Jackson ImmunoResearch | 106-546-003 | |
Goat anti-Rabbit IgG (H+L) Secondary Antibody, Alexa Fluor 488 conjugate | Molecular Probes (Invitrogen GmbH) | A-11008 | |
Click-iT EdU Alexa Fluor 594 Imaging Kit | Invitrogen | C10339 | |
Click-iT EdU Alexa Fluor 488 Flow Cytometry Assay Kit | Invitrogen | C10425 | |
12-well filter inserts (thincerts) | Greiner bio-one | 657631 | |
12-well plate | Greiner | 665180-01 | |
Jettex 2005/45 | ORSA, Giorla Minore, Italy | ||
Fibrinogen TISSUECOL-Kit Immuno | Baxter | ||
Thrombin TISSUECOL-Kit Immuno | Baxter | ||
PBS | Serva | 47302.03 | |
DMEM | Lonza | BE12-604F | |
DMEM/F12 | Lonza | BE12-719F | |
HEPES | Gibco | 15630-049 | |
FBS Gold | GE Healthcare | A11-151 | |
Aprotinin (Trasylol) | Bayer | 4032037 | |
Cholera toxin | Biomol | G117 | |
Hydrocortisone | Seromed (Biochrom) | K3520 | |
L-ascorbic acid | Sigma | A4034 | |
TGF-ß1 | Invitrogen | PHG9214 | |
RANKL | R&D systems | 462-TR-010 | |
Thermolysin | Sigma Aldrich | T-7902 | |
OCT Compound | TissueTek | 4583 | |
Trizol (aka. Denaturing solution – Acid guanidinium thiocyanate-phenol-chloroform extraction) | Invitrogen | 10296028 | |
FastPrep FP120 | Thermo Scientific | ||
Collagenase Type IV | CellSystems | LS004189 | 0.2 mg/ml and 57U/ml final conc. |
Neutrale Protease (Dispase) | CellSystems | LS002104 | 0.2 mg/ml and 1.2U/ml final conc. |
DNase I | Roche | 11 284 932 001 | 25 µg/ml final conc. |