Preparation of mitochondria-enriched samples from previously frozen archived solid tissues allowed the investigators to perform both functional and analytical assessments of mitochondria in various experimental modalities. This study demonstrates how to prepare mitochondria-enriched preparations from frozen heart tissue and perform analytical assessments of mitochondria.
The mitochondrial electron transfer complex (ETC) profile is modified in the heart tissue of the offspring born to an exercised sow. The hypothesis proposed and tested was that a regular maternal exercise of a sow during pregnancy would increase the mitochondrial efficiency of offspring heart bioenergetics. This hypothesis was tested by isolating mitochondria using a mild-isolation procedure to assess mitochondrial ETC and supercomplex profiles. The procedure described here allowed for the processing of previously frozen archived heart tissues and eliminated the necessity of fresh mitochondria preparation for the assessment of mitochondrial ETC complexes, supercomplexes, and ETC complex activity profiles. This protocol describes the optimal ETC protein complex measurement in multiplexed antibody-based immunoblotting and super complex assessment using blue-native gel electrophoresis.
The goal of this protocol was to provide detailed steps to obtain mitochondria-enriched preparation from previously frozen heart tissue with a new technology of low energy mechanical disruption of tissue that improves tissue lysis and extraction of mitochondria. With this method, improved extraction efficiency without generating high shear stress or high temperature and short homogenization time (10-12 s) become achievable1.
To obtain mitochondria from archived frozen tissue is a valuable asset to perform both functional2 and biochemical studies3 otherwise not easily repeatable under the exact experimental conditions. A classic Potter-Elvehjem Teflon pestle glass homogenizer or Dounce homogenizer has been used and is still being used in research laboratories to homogenize soft tissues such as liver, kidney, and brain. However, homogenizing hard tissues such as muscle and heart require more homogenization time, enzyme treatment, high-speed homogenization, and extensive user experience. This is disadvantageous for extracting intact organelles such as mitochondria from hard tissue such as muscle and heart. The method described in this protocol is used to obtain high yield mitochondria-enriched preparation to analyze mitochondrial electron transport chain (ETC) protein complexes and their supercomplex formation in heart tissues harvested from offspring born to exercised and sedentary sow, flash-frozen in liquid nitrogen, and stored at -80 °C for future use. This method allows the user to isolate mitochondria enriched preparation from previously frozen archived tissues.
External nanomaterial exposure to pregnant rodents can negatively affect cardiac function and mitochondrial respiration and bioenergetics on progeny during gestation4. Nevertheless, aerobic exercise-induced positive changes in fetal myocyte bioenergetics during pregnancy are yet to be documented. However, emerging studies provide evidence that maternal aerobic exercise during pregnancy has a positive influence on fetal cardiac function5. In order to provide further evidence, an analysis of the longitudinal effects of maternal exercise on offspring cardiac mitochondrial respiratory chain complexes (i.e., Complex I through Complex V) during pregnancy was performed.
This study has significant health relevance since the results may suggest that maternal exercise improves the efficiency of energy production in the cardiac mitochondria of the offspring. In this study, sows (female pig) were used as an animal model for two reasons: (i) cardiac physiology is similar to human6, and (ii) heart tissue harvest from offspring from different time points is feasible under an institutional IACUC approval. The proposed study aims to answer many of the fundamental questions linking maternal exercise and its potential positive effects on the cellular and biochemical makeup of the offspring's heart tissue. This approach requires gentle yet effective mitochondria isolation techniques from previously frozen cardiac tissue obtained from the lengthy and costly longitudinal studies that addressed the issues of the bioenergetic changes within fetal cardiac myocytes during the pregnancy. The method described in this study allows utilizing large sums of previously frozen archived tissue for mitochondria-enriched preparation for both analytical and functional studies. The study will also help fill the knowledge gap in this field by providing preliminary data, which could lead to future studies determining the effects of maternal exercise on heart health in utero and beyond.
Frozen offspring heart tissues were received from Dr. Sean Newcomer along with the institutional IACUC approval letter. The heart tissues were obtained from a long-term longitudinal study, flash-frozen in liquid nitrogen, and stored at -80 °C for future use. All protocols concerning the processing of offspring heart tissue followed the guidelines of Kansas City University IBC and IACUC committees.
1. Preparation of buffers and reagents
NOTE: Prepare all samples as per the manufacturer's guidelines. Use ultra-purified water or equivalent in all recipes and protocol steps. Wear personal protection equipment (lab gloats, facemask, gloves, and goggles/face shield) during this procedure. Buffer volumes are suitable for processing six tissue samples.
2. Mitochondria isolation from frozen heart tissue
NOTE: Perform the mitochondria isolation procedure in a 4 °C cold room. However, in case of unavailability of the cold room, use a large size ice bath to perform the procedure.
Figure 1: Tissue shredder chamber (tube) for use with the shredder. Tissue homogenization in the shredder tube requires about 10-12 s per tissue sample. Tissue homogenization is completed once the homogenized tissue passes through the perforated disk into the upper chamber. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 1: Tissue shredder chamber (tube) for use with the shredder. Tissue homogenization in the shredder tube requires about 10-12 s per tissue sample. Tissue homogenization is completed once the homogenized tissue passes through the perforated disk into the upper chamber. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
3. Mitochondrial electron transfer complex (ETC) assessment
NOTE: Individual mitochondrial ETC proteins (i.e., Complex-I, II, III, IV, V) can be assessed by standard immunoblotting assay. Due to the variety of samples (four time points: 48 h, 3 months,6 months, 9 months), two experimental conditions (exercised and sedentary), and a number of immunoprobing antibodies (five antibodies), a multiplexed immunoblotting is recommended. Perform multiplexed immunoblotting as follows.
4. The mitochondria supercomplex assessment by Blue Native Poly Acrylamide Gel Electrophoresis (BN-PAGE)
NOTE: A supercomplex profile of ETC can also be assessed by employing the BN-PAGE technique.
Protein | Digitonin/protein | 4x Sample Buffer | 5% Digitonin | Water | Final volume | 5% Coomassie G-250 |
ratio (g/g) | sample additive | |||||
50 µg | 8 | 5 | 8 | 7 | 20 | 2 |
50 µg | 4 | 5 | 4 | 11 | 20 | 1 |
Table 1: Sample Buffer Cocktail Preparation with two different detergent/protein ratios. To achieve maximum solubilization of membrane proteins from the mitochondrial suspension, the digitonin/mitochondrial suspension protein concentration should be adjusted to between 4-8 g digitonin/g of protein. In the heart tissue, 400 µg digitonin for 50 µg of mitochondrial suspension proteins (i.e., 8 g digitonin/g of mitochondria protein) were used to maximize the solubility of the supercomplexes from the mitochondria suspension.
5. Mitochondria supercomplex assessment by immunoblot blot analysis
Following the protocol, a good yield of mitochondria-enriched protein mixture from heart tissue was prepared. Approximately 15 mg/mL of mitochondria-enriched protein mixture was obtained from an average of 1.2 g frozen heart tissue harvested from the offspring of the sow. Observations indicated that less than 0.5 g of frozen heart tissue did not yield a sufficient amount of mitochondrial-enriched protein mixture to carry out a BN-PAGE assay. The amount of mitochondrial preparation was sufficient to perform (i) a standard immunoblot analysis for assessing the individual electron transfer complexes (ETC) (i.e., Complex-I, II, III, IV, and Complex-V), (ii) a mitochondrial supercomplex assessment by BN-PAGE and immunoblot analysis, and (iii) limited enzymatic assays for the select complex. The cocktail of antibodies raised against individual ETC protein complexes provides technical feasibility that each antibody will recognize its own target protein in one single immunoblot assay.
Mitochondria-enriched protein was prepared from the left ventricle of the heart, obtained from the offspring of the sow. The offspring were born to two groups of sows: (1) one group was exercised during pregnancy and (2) one group was sedentary. The heart tissues of both the groups were harvested at different time points after the birth (48 h, 3 months, 6 months, and 9 months). Whether maternal exercise has a positive impact on mitochondrial ETC of the offspring during gestation was the hypothesis that was tested in this study. Four heart tissues were comfortably processed on any given day due to the lengthy mitochondria-enriched isolation process.
Figure 2: Immunoblot profile of mitochondrial ETC complexes from offspring heart tissue. The mitochondrial-enriched protein mixture was resolved in a 4%-20% gradient gel under reducing conditions. Proteins were immunoprobed by a commercial antibody cocktail, and anti-VDAC antibody was used for loading control (red color band). The cocktail of antibodies was raised against bovine heart Complex-I (antigen NDUFB8), bovine heart Complex-II (antigen C-II30 (FeS), bovine heart Complex II, III (antigen C-III-Core 2), human Complex IV, subunit II (antigen C-IV-II), and bovine heart Complex-V (antigen C-V-α). The secondary antibody was labeled with an infrared tag, and the image was analyzed using an image analyzing software. Individual Complex profiles across the age groups are provided in Supplemental Figure 1 (A–E). Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 2 represents a typical ETC protein profile. Antibody cocktails allowed for immunoblotting in a multiplex format. Each antibody recognized its own target protein, providing an acceptable resolution. The protein band intensities were digitally analyzed. Tissues obtained from the offspring of exercised sow presented relatively reduced levels in some of the ETC complexes (Supplemental Figures 1A–E). The mitochondria-enriched preparation must be resolved in a gradient gel (4%-20%) as the immunoprobing was performed in a multiplexing format. This approach will eliminate the necessity of running several fixed percent of SDS/PAGE gels and run-to-run variability.
Mitochondrial proteins were resolved in a 3%-8% gradient BN-PAGE (Figure 3A) and immunoprobed with antibody cocktails. In both exercised and sedentary groups, multiple supercomplex formation was observed (Figure 3B).
Figure 3: Mitochondrial supercomplex profile by Blue-Native Polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (BN-PAGE). (A). Mitochondrial-enriched protein mixtures were resolved in 3%-8% BN-PAGE, and stained with a Coomassie blue reagent (Gel Code, Blue Stain Reagent). (B). Mitochondrial-enriched protein mixtures were resolved in a 3%-8% BN-PAGE, transferred onto a PVDF membrane, and immunoprobed with the antibody cocktails for supercomplexes. In both assays, the protein load was 150 µg/well. A 6-month data collection point was not included due to an insufficient protein yield during the preparation. The most prominent supercomplex increase observed was at 9 months in the exercised group compared to the sedentary group. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
A different gradient gel format (3%-8%) was prepared due to the large size of the supercomplexes that can be resolved in BN-PAGE. Mitochondria-enriched preparation described in this protocol was used for measuring mitochondrial ETC complex activities. Figure 4 represents data recorded for Complex I-II activity assessment. This assay was performed according to the established protocol3.
Figure 4: Complex I-II activity measurements. Mitochondria-enriched protein mixtures obtained from different age groups (48 h, 3 months, 6 months, and 9 months) were analyzed for the Complex I-II activity using a kinetic assay. The exercised group showed an increased Complex I-II activity as compare to that of the sedentary group. The difference between the two groups was not statistically significant according to a paired t-test (P > 0.05). The error bars depicted in the figure represent the standard error of the mean (SEM) for n = 4. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Supplemental Figure 1: (A) Complex-I profile across age groups. In general, offspring born to the exercised sow presented with lower levels of Complex-I compared to that of the sedentary group (n = 4). This was more pronounced in the 9-month group. (B) Complex-II profile across age groups. All age groups showed low levels of Complex-II in the exercised group with the exception of three months cohort (n = 4). (C) Complex-III profile across age groups. Only the 9-month age group showed lower levels of Complex-III in the exercised group as compared to that of the sedentary group (n = 4). (D) Complex-IV profile across age groups. A slight increase in the Complex-IV protein levels of the exercised group was observed (n = 4). (E) The Complex-V (ATP synthase) profile across age groups. Both exercised and sedentary groups exhibited low levels of Complex-V except at the 48 h data point (n = 4). Please click here to download this File.
The critical steps for this protocol are indicated here. First, tissue homogenization should be carefully handled so that excessive sheer effects will not be applied during the tissue homogenization process. A tissue shredder should be used, which is a part of pressure cycling technology (PCT) for initial tissue homogenization9. This step will reduce the excessive stroke cycle of glass-on-glass homogenizer (Figure 1B) that may further destroy already fragile mitochondria due to frozen tissue conditions. Second, the frozen tissue weight will be important to obtain sufficient amounts of the mitochondria-enriched preparation. The recommended starting tissue amount will be greater than 0.8 g, depending on the source of the tissue. The heart tissue is very rich in mitochondria10,11; therefore, the recommended amount will be sufficient to obtain a mitochondria-enriched preparation. Third, all procedures should be performed in a cold room. If a cold room is not available, a large-sized ice bath will be sufficient.
The feasibility of obtaining mitochondria-enriched preparations from previously frozen heart tissue has been demonstrated in this study. This protocol will be essential for providing access to archived frozen tissue from which mitochondria can be isolated and from which mitochondrial ETC enzyme complexes can be assessed. A recent study demonstrated that mitochondrial respiration from previously frozen tissues and cells could be measurable as well2. Because of this advancement, investigators will be able to utilize previously collected biosamples for further analyses.
To assess the profile of individual ETC and supercomplexes is made easier by performing classical immunoblotting in a multiplexing format that utilizes multiple antibodies during the immunoblotting procedure on the same PVDH membrane. It is critical for the user to determine the amount of protein to be loaded into gels for SDS-PAGE and BN-PAGE. The resuspension volume should be as minimal as possible in order to obtain high protein concentrations so that the user will not have a problem with sample loading volume. The protein amount to be loaded in BN-PAGE depends on the yield of the mitochondria-enriched preparation. A 150 µg of mitochondria-enriched protein mixture was loaded per well in BN-PAGE due to the small amount of original heart tissue. The 50-150 µg mitochondria-enriched pellet preparation would be sufficient for 1 mm thick gel. The user may prefer a 1.5 mm thick gel for sample loading; however, the resolution of protein bands may not be of acceptable quality. The less mitochondrial protein resuspension per well was not tested because antibody cocktails used in immunoblot assays were predetermined in their concentration; however, users can make their own antibody cocktail to increase the signal/noise rate.
A fully polymerized gradient gel (3%-8%) for BN-PAGE gels is recommended. Gradient gels of 3%-8% have not been commercially available; therefore, homemade gradient (3%-8%) standard mini gels (9 x 6 cm) can be used. Pouring the gel 24 h before and allowing for the gel to polymerize overnight in RT will provide an acceptable gel formation. If a user needs better separation of supercomplexes, it is recommended to use larger gel formats (either midi gel 13.5 cm x 6.5 cm or long gel 28 cm x 16 cm).
The application of this protocol will allow investigators to isolate mitochondria and analyze the profile of ETC and supercomplexes in previously frozen archived tissues. All national and regional biospecimen depositories keep the biosamples in ultra-freezing conditions (i.e., -80 °C). Large number of tissues are being archived by institutions and drug companies for further studies and reagent sharing purposes. The National Institute of Health (NIH) mandates that any NIH-supported projects are required to share the reagents produced from the supported projects. These biorepositories are very valuable sources for obtaining frozen archived tissues for obtaining preliminary data for grant applications. To analyze enzyme activities of supercomplexes was not performed in this study; however, protocols are available to perform such assays8.
Using the methods described in this paper, individual ETC complexes and supercomplexes of mitochondria-enriched preparations obtained from the heart tissue of the offspring of sows were analyzed. Offspring born to exercised sows presented low levels of ETC during the first 6 months of their life and eventually leveling up by 9 months.
ETC Complex | 48 h | 3 month | 6 month | 9 month |
Complex-I | ↓ | ↓ | ↓ | No change |
Complex-II | ↓ | ↓ | No change | No change |
Complex-III | ↓ | No change | No change | ↓ |
Complex-IV | ↑ | ↑ | ↑ | No change |
Complex-V | ↓ | ↓ | ↓ | No change |
Table 2: Mitochondrial electron transport chain protein complexes profile. The table summarizes the profile of mitochondrial ETC complex levels in the exercised group of sows. All complexes, except Complex-IV, showed a decreasing pattern across the age groups.
This observation may suggest that offspring born to the exercised sows during the pregnancy indicated fewer but more efficient ETC complexes in their heart tissue mitochondria (Figure 4). However, supercomplex formation in 9 months exercised group has been found to be elevated. Exercise may somehow affect the rearrangement of supercomplexes in conditions of increased energy demand12. In addition, Complex-V (ATP synthase) has exhibited a low profile in the first 6 months after birth. This response may be due to the probability of epigenetically modified ETC protein complexes. The small sample size (n = 4) for this study was not sufficient to arrive at such a conclusion; however, patterns of low ETC complex protein levels, high Complex I-II activity, and elevated supercomplex formation may suggest that bioenergetics in heart tissue of the progeny of exercised sows are influenced by exercise. Fewer but more efficiently working mitochondrial ETC complexes and the formation of increased supercomplexes are interesting phenomena to be investigated. This project is still in progress.
In summary, this protocol provides simple and straightforward mitochondria-enriched sample preparation from previously frozen archived heart tissue. Mitochondrial ETC complexes can be analyzed by standard immunoblotting with multiplexed antibody cocktails. BN-PAGE followed by immunoblotting can analyze the presence of supercomplexes. This preparation can also allow users to assess mitochondrial ETC complex activities.
The authors have nothing to disclose.
This work was financially supported by Kansas City University's intramural grant for Abdulbaki Agbas and Summer Research Fellowship for Daniel Barrera. The authors are thankful for Dr. Jan Talley's editorial work.
Amino caproic acid | Sigma/Aldrich | A2504-100G | |
Anti-Hu Total OxPhos complex kit | Invitrogen | 458199 | |
anti-VDAC antibody | abcam | ab15895 | use 1 µg/mL |
Coomassie G-250 | ThermoSientific | 20279 | |
Coomassie GelCode Blue | ThermoScientific | 24592 | |
Digitonin | Cabiochem | 300410 | |
Glass-Glass pestle homogenizer | VWR | KT885451-0020 | |
Image Studio | LICOR | ||
IR-Dye conjugated anti-Rabbit Ab | LICOR | LC0725 | |
Multiwell plate reader | BioTek | Synergy HT | |
Native molecular weight marker | ThermoFisher | BN2001 | |
Nylon mesh monofilament | Small Part Inc | CMN-74 | |
Orbital shaker | ThermoScientfic | ||
PCT Shredder | Pressure Bioscience Inc | ||
SEA BLOCK Blocking buffer | ThermoScienctific | 37527 | |
Shredder PULSE Tube | Pressure Bioscience Inc | FT500-PS | |
Table top centrifuge | Eppendorf | 5418 | |
Trypsin | Amresco | M150-1G | |
Trypsin inhibitor | Amresco | M191-1G | Requires fresh preparation |