Here, a protocol to perform and analyze the binding, mobility, and assembly of single molecules on artificial crowded lipid membranes using single-molecule total internal reflection fluorescence (smTIRF) microscopy is presented.
Cellular membranes are highly crowded environments for biomolecular reactions and signaling. Yet, most in vitro experiments probing protein interaction with lipids employ naked bilayer membranes. Such systems lack the complexities of crowding by membrane-embedded proteins and glycans and exclude the associated volume effects encountered on cellular membrane surfaces. Also, the negatively charged glass surface onto which the lipid bilayers are formed prevents the free diffusion of transmembrane biomolecules. Here, we present a well-characterized polymer-lipid membrane as a mimic for crowded lipid membranes. This protocol utilizes polyethylene glycol (PEG)-conjugated lipids as a generalized approach for incorporating crowders into the supported lipid bilayer (SLB). First, a cleaning procedure of the microscopic slides and coverslips for performing single-molecule experiments is presented. Next, methods for characterizing the PEG-SLBs and performing single-molecule experiments of the binding, diffusion, and assembly of biomolecules using single-molecule tracking and photobleaching are discussed. Finally, this protocol demonstrates how to monitor the nanopore assembly of bacterial pore-forming toxin Cytolysin A (ClyA) on crowded lipid membranes with single-molecule photobleaching analysis. MATLAB codes with example datasets are also included to perform some of the common analyses such as particle tracking, extracting diffusive behavior, and subunit counting.
Cellular membranes are highly crowded and complex systems1. Molecular crowding can have a considerable impact on the diffusion of membrane-bound entities like protein and lipids2,3,4. Similarly, bimolecular reactions on lipid membranes like receptor dimerization or the oligomerization of membrane complexes are influenced by crowding5,6,7. The nature, configuration, and concentration of crowders can govern the membrane binding, diffusivity, and protein-protein interaction in several ways8,9. Since controlling membrane crowding on cellular membranes and interpreting its influence on embedded biomolecules is challenging, researchers have tried to establish alternate in vitro systems10.
A popular approach for artificial crowded membranes is doping the bilayer membranes with polymer (such as polyethylene glycol, PEG)-grafted lipids11,12. During the visualization of protein and lipid dynamics on supported lipid bilayers (SLBs), these polymers additionally shield the membrane-embedded components from the underlying negatively charged substrate (such as glass) by effectively lifting the bilayer away from the underlying support. By varying the size and concentration of the polymer, one can control the extent of molecular crowding, as well as its separation from the underlying solid support13,14. This is clearly an advantage over lipid bilayers supported on solid substrates without polymer cushions15,16, where transmembrane biomolecules can lose their activity17,18,19. More importantly, it allows us to recapitulate the crowded environment of the cell membrane in vitro, which is critical for many membrane processes.
Surface-grafted polymers on membranes also undergo changes in their configuration depending on their grafting density12. At low concentrations, they remain in an entropically coiled configuration, known as a mushroom, above the membrane surface. With increasing concentration, they start to interact and tend to uncoil and extend, finally yielding a dense brush-like formation on the membrane21. Since the transition from the mushroom to the brush regime is highly heterogeneous and manifests in poorly characterized conditions of the polymer, it is important to use well-characterized conditions for crowding on polymer-grafted membranes. Compared to a recent study20, we identify and report crowded membrane compositions that maintain the diffusive transport and activity of transmembrane biomolecules.
In this protocol, we discuss how to generate PEGylated lipid membranes and provide recommendations for PEG densities that mimic crowding in two different regimes of polymer configuration (namely, mushroom and brush). The protocol also describes single-molecule binding, particle tracking, and photobleaching data acquisition and analysis for molecules embedded in these crowded membranes. First, we describe the thorough cleaning steps, the assembly of the imaging chamber, and the generation of PEG-SLBs. Second, we provide details for the single-molecule binding, particle tracking, and photobleaching experiments. Third, we discuss i) extracting the relative binding affinities, ii) characterizing molecular diffusion, and iii) counting subunits in a protein assembly from movies of single molecules on the membrane.
While we characterized this system with single-molecule imaging, the protocol is useful for all membrane biophysicists interested in understanding the effect of crowding on biomolecular reactions on lipid membranes. Overall, we present a robust pipeline for making crowded and supported lipid bilayers, along with various single-molecule assays conducted on them and the corresponding analysis routines.
1. Cleaning of the slide and coverslip for single-molecule experiments
2. Assembly of the microfluidic chamber
NOTE: The imaging chamber is created by sandwiching double-sided tape between a pre-cleaned coverslip and slide from the previous step as described below.
3. Making supported bilayers on glass substrate by vesicle fusion
NOTE: Crowded supported lipid bilayers are generated on the walls of the imaging chamber by the fusion of lipid vesicles prepared with doped PEG-lipids.
4. Microscope setup and single-particle imaging measurements
NOTE: Single-molecule experiments are carried out on an objective-based total internal reflection fluorescence24,25,26 (TIRF) microscope setup (Figure 2). TIRF imaging provides a better signal-to-noise ratio for single-molecule imaging, though epi-fluorescence microscopes can also be used under certain conditions (especially when the fluorescent biomolecules can be removed from the bulk solution by washing). The prism-type TIRF can be used but the objective-type is preferable for the ease of setting up microfluidics27. For objective-type TIRF, a high numerical aperture objective (100x magnification, usually commercially available as a TIRF objective) is recommended.
5. Image acquisition for counting subunits in a protein assembly
NOTE: Image acquisition for estimating stoichiometry requires continuous bleaching of fluorophores and detecting the number of steps until no more fluorophores are emitting fluorescence.
6. Image and data analysis
Monitoring the binding of ClyA protein on PEGylated membranes
After step 4.5, the binding kinetics are estimated by plotting the number of particles binding to the membrane surface over time (Video 1). As ClyA protein binds to a membrane with 5 mol% PEG2000 lipids,the particle density increases and reaches saturation (Figure 5). An exponential decay fit to the bound particles (cyan circles) gives the time constant (τb) for the membrane binding (notably, the initial time points [red circles] are not fit in this case).
Mobility of DNA tracer on crowded membranes
We commonly use DNA tracers (DNA anchored to the membrane with a tocopherol), lipophilic tracer dyes (e.g., DiI), or membrane proteins (e.g., ClyA) to characterize the membrane under PEG-mediated crowding. Lateral diffusion of labeled tracer molecules (25–100 pM) can be monitored by imaging the membrane upon particle binding. In the absence of any PEG polymer in the membrane, most tracers (especially those extending outside the bilayer) display restricted diffusion on SLBs (Figure 6A). With small levels of PEG2000 in the membrane (0.5–2 mol%), the bilayer lifts away from the underlying surface, and the tracer molecules can diffuse without constraints. On the other hand, extreme confinement is observed at a high concentration of PEG (20 mol%), where PEG molecules are in a dense brush regime, with a variety of behaviors displayed in between. MSD plots for these three conditions are shown in Figure 6B. Based on our characterization of POPC/DOPE-PEG2000 bilayer membranes, we recommend a 1–3 mol% DOPE-PEG2000 fraction that induces crowding in the mushroom regime. Above 7.5 mol% PEG2000-lipid, we observe the onset of the brush regime, and compositions until 25 mol% PEG2000-lipid can be employed to induce crowding and confinement. The intervening 4–7% PEG2000-lipid conditions corresponding to the transition between the two regimes are poorly characterized and should be avoided.
Assembly of ClyA on crowded membranes
The intensity trajectories of individual diffraction-limited spots of ClyA protein after incubation on the crowded membrane (Figure 7A,B) display a large number of distinct photobleaching steps, suggesting the formation of various assembly intermediates31. ClyA, being a transmembrane protein, interacts with the negatively charged glass surface in the absence of PEG and will assemble very poorly. At 7.5 mol% PEG2000 lipids, the assembled complexes were measured and are plotted in Figure 7C. After correcting for the labeling efficiency (0.9 in this case), the final distribution of oligomers displays the dodecameric ClyA species as the dominant structure, consistent with structural data32.
Figure 1: Schematic for the cleaning steps and microfluidic chamber assembly. (A) The glass slides and the coverslips are cleaned with sequential sonication in detergent, acetone, methanol, KOH, and piranha solution, with multiple rinsing by type 1 ultrapure water between each step. The slides and coverslips are then dried with nitrogen gas before plasma treatment. (B) The microfluidic imaging chamber is then assembled using a pre-cut double-sided adhesive tape that binds the slide to the coverslip. *Acrylic slides are not treated with piranha solution, and the acetone, methanol, and KOH are used at a 50% (v/v) concentration of that used for coverslip cleaning. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 2: TIRF microscope setup. A typical objective-type TIRF microscope setup adapted on an inverted microscope is shown with essential optics highlighted. M1–M5 are mirrors to steer the laser beam. Lenses L1 and L2 are used to expand the laser beam, and the L3 lens focuses the laser beam onto the back focal plane of the objective lens. I1 and I2 are the Iris diaphragms used to align the laser beam. A shutter is used to control the laser beam illumination, critical for preventing unnecessary photobleaching of the fluorescence molecules. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 3: Membrane binding kinetics flow setup. For conducting the binding experiment, a thin PTFE tubing (0.022 in ID x 0.042 in OD) is used to flow the sample with the help of a syringe pump (image not to scale). The end of the tubing is connected to the imaging chamber outlet with the help of a micropipette tip. The discard is collected in a small microtip reservoir plugged into the outlet, and the volume introduced is always greater than 10 times the volume of the imaging chamber. Inset figure showing cross section of the imaging chamber. (image not to scale) Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 4: Pipeline for analysis from single-particle trajectories and photobleaching movies. (A) The acquired movies were analyzed using u-track in MATLAB to obtain the trajectories as (x, y) and the intensities (i) of each particle, frame-by-frame. These trajectories were then used to calculate instantaneous square displacement (ISD), ISD1, and ISD2. The ISDs can then be plotted as histograms to identify mobile species. Alternately, mean squared displacement (MSD) plots inform whether the motion is Gaussian, confined, or super-diffusive33,34. Hidden Markov Model35 (HMM) analysis can be employed to distinguish different diffusive states of a single particle. (B) For the photobleaching analysis, the movies were first corrected for drift in the system (if necessary), followed by particle detection or tracking using u-track. Apart from estimating the intensity distribution23 (and other particle features), the intensity trajectories can be analyzed for the number of photobleaching steps using step-finding algorithms36,37,38. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 5: Binding of ClyA to supported lipid membranes with 5 mol% DOPE-PEG2000. A typical binding curve is obtained after counting the number of particles in each frame identified by u-track. Imaging is initiated before the flow of the membrane-binding ClyA protein. An exponential decay function (black line) fit to particle numbers (cyan circles) is used to recover the time constant for the binding of ClyA to the membrane. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 6: Mobility of lipophilic DNA on PEG-lipid bilayer membranes. (A) Schematic for the lipophilic DNA tracer in the POPC/DOPE-PEG2000 membrane is shown. (B) Mean squared displacements calculated from the single-particle tracking for different PEG-SLBs are shown. In 2 mol% DOPE-PEG2000, DNA tracer displays pure Brownian behavior compared to hindered mobility in the absence of the polymer (dashed line is included for reference). On the other hand, the same DNA tracer deviates away from pure Brownian diffusion, indicating sub-diffusive motion with reduced mobility in the presence of 20 mol% DOPE-PEG2000. (C) ISD2 distribution for the diffusion of lipophilic DNA tracer in two different PEG2000 lipid membranes is compared to bare SLBs. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 7: Photobleaching traces and the assembly of ClyA on lipid bilayer membranes. (A,B) Representative time traces show photobleaching steps of ClyA nanopore complex detected in step 6.2.1. for an assembled ClyA complex with 7 and 5 steps, respectively. (C) The photobleaching step distribution (grey) for ClyA (25 nM) incubated on 64.7% POPC: 27.8% Cholesterol: 7.5% DOPE-PEG2000 membrane for 60 min at 37 °C is shown. After correcting for the incomplete labeling efficiency, the estimated mass fraction of various oligomeric species (magenta) is shown. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Video 1: Binding of ClyA on the membrane. Monitoring Cy3-labeled ClyA protein binding to the SLB membrane containing 5 mol% DOPE-PEG2000. The bound particles are detected (cyan circles) by u-track, and tracks are plotted for five subsequent positions in their trajectory. Please click here to download this Video.
Video 2: Diffusion of DNA tracer on the 2 mol% PEG membrane. A movie for Cy3-labeled DNA anchored to the lipid membrane via tocopherol in the 2 mol% PEG2000 membrane. Please click here to download this Video.
Video 3: Photobleaching movie. A movie of assembled oligomers of Cy3-labeled ClyA molecules on the membrane containing 7.5 mol% DOPE-PEG2000. Larger complexes are evident from the several fold higher intensities compared to a single protein, as well as from the multiple photobleaching steps when particle intensity is observed over time under continuous illumination. Please click here to download this Video.
Supplementary File 1: Information on how to use u-track and different MATLAB codes in step 6. Please click here to download this File.
Supplementary Coding File 1: A representative computer-aided design (CAD) file for making holes in the acrylic slide and cutting tape for the entire slide. Please click here to download this File.
Supplementary Coding Files 2: Compressed folder containing associated MATLAB codes needed for image and data analysis in step 6. Please click here to download this File.
Supplementary Coding Files 3: Sample data for image and data analysis in step 6. The MATLAB codes are also available at https://github.com/sgmaurya/SMTrack_Analysis. Please click here to download this File.
Here, we demonstrate single-molecule experiments on supported lipid bilayers (SLBs) that manifest a crowded environment for membrane-embedded biomolecules. The crowded environment generates an excluded volume effect, leading to the enhancement of biomolecular reactions1,2,39,40. For the PEG-lipid system, where the polymer primarily occupies the volume outside the bilayer, this effect is especially pronounced for molecular species with large ecto-domains. Therefore, compared to lipophilic dyes, the diffusion of a large hydrophilic molecule embedded in the membrane, such as receptors, glycoproteins, and glycolipids can be significantly reduced. Using fluorescent tracer DNA anchored to the membrane via tocopherol (Figure 5), we can identify such crowding effects.
Separately, the presence of PEG in the bottom leaflet also lifts the SLB and reduces the interaction of the biomolecules with the support substrate14,41. Usually, the negatively charged surface of the imaging glass surface frequently hinders mobility and molecular reactions. Therefore, the use of PEG-lipids to lift the membrane away from the glass is advantageous even when not for the purpose of crowding. However, care must be taken to identify the concentration regimes that do not manifest molecular crowding in those cases. For proteins extending larger domains outside the bilayer, the use of a higher molecular weight PEG-lipid such as PEG5000 might be necessary42.
A few key points are critical to the single-molecule imaging on SLB systems. Rigorous cleaning of the slides and coverslips is critical in single-molecule experiments (step 1). Imaging a surface with impurities will result in defects in the lipid membrane. This can result in patches of fluorescently labeled biomolecules on the membrane surface. The coverage and uniformity of SLB formed can be verified in a separate preparation by doping the bilayer with a lipid dye (DiI or Lissamine Rhodamine DOPE) and imaging it under a fluorescence microscope. FRAP analysis can be used to benchmark the diffusive behavior as well43,44.
For membrane binding experiments (step 4), the flow setup with the tubing should be primed with buffer to prevent the entry of air bubbles into the chamber. Higher flow rates or the presence of air bubbles will rupture the membrane, and the molecules will bind to the coverslip directly. Image acquisition should start before the flow starts as some molecules diffuse from the tubing and bind to the membrane. Focusing the objective on the bilayer during imaging can be facilitated by doping the bilayer at a low concentration with gold nanoparticles, quantum dots, or fluorescent beads.
For the single-particle tracking experiments, the number of particles on the membrane should be controlled to avoid a scenario where the tracking is challenging due to excessive overlap of the particle trajectories. Another important factor to consider during the imaging is the laser power. A high laser power will photobleach the fluorophores quickly, while low intensity and the corresponding slow image acquisition rates will cause blurring. Optimal laser power should yield a significant trajectory length (at least >5 on average) while maintaining symmetric and close to diffraction-limited images of particles. An oxygen scavenging system can also be used to prolong the photobleaching of fluorophores45. A limitation of the photobleaching analysis presented here arises37,46 in the case of large molecular assemblies (~ greater than 20 subunits), such as the nuclear pore complex47. In such cases, a Bayesian-based approach can be utilized to infer the subunit population48,49,50.
The labeling of biomolecules with fluorophores in most cases is not complete51. This poses a challenge in counting subunits in a cluster with unlabeled species. A binomial correction for the sub-par labeling efficiency is usually a reasonable approximation when the stoichiometry of the molecular species is fixed. In many cases, oligomeric species could be heterogeneous or dynamically changing, as in an oligomerization process, requiring the development of new tools for extracting the underlying distributions from photobleaching data.
Overall, this protocol provides a pipeline for generating PEG-SLBs, with recommendations for the conditions to use, perform and analyze single-molecule binding, and tracking and perform photobleaching analysis for membrane biomolecules.
The authors have nothing to disclose.
The authors acknowledge Prof. Benjamin Schuler for sharing the expression plasmid for ClyA protein. This work was supported by Human Frontier Science Program (RGP0047-2020).
2.5 ml Syringes | HMD Healthcare | Dispo Van, 2.5 ml Tuberculin | Plastic syringe |
Acetone | Finar Chemicals | 10020LL025 | |
Acrylic Sheet | 2 mm thick | ||
Acrylic Sheet | BigiMall | 2 mm, Clear | |
Bath Sonicator | Branson | CPX-1800 | |
Calcium Chloride | |||
Chloroform | Sigma | 528730 | HPLC grade |
Cholesterol | Avanti | 700100 | |
Coplin Jar | Duran Wheaton Kimble | S6016 | 8 Slide Jar with Glass Cover |
Coverslips | VWR | 631-1574 | 24 mm X 50 mm |
Cy3-DNA Strand | IDT | GCTGCTATTGCGTCCGTTTGGTT GGTGTGGTTGG-Cy3 |
|
Cyanine Dye (Cy3) | Cytiva Life Sciences | PA23001 | |
DiI | Invitrogen | D3911 | Dil Stain (1,1'-Dioctadecyl-3,3,3',3'-Tetramethylindocarbocyanine Perchlorate ('DiI'; DiIC18(3))) |
DNA Connector Strand 1 | Sigma Aldrich | GCTGCTATTGCGTCCGTTTAGCT GGGGGAGTATTGCGGAGGAAGC T |
|
DNA Connector Strand 2 | Sigma Aldrich | CGGACGCAATAGCAGCTCACAG TCGGTCACAT |
|
DNA Tocopherol Strand | Biomers | Toco-CCCAATGTGACCGACTGTGA | |
DOPE-PEG2000 | Avanti | 880130 | 1,2-dioleoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphoethanolamine-N-[methoxy(polyethylene glycol)-2000] (ammonium salt) |
Double Sided Tape | 3M | LF93010LE | |
Drill Bits (Diamond Coated) | 0.5 – 1 mm | ||
Drilling Machine | Dremel | 220 | Workstation |
EMCCD | Andor | DU-897U-CS0-#BV | |
Fluorescence Beads | Invitrogen | F10720 | |
Glass Slides | Blue Star | Micro Slides, PIC-1 | |
Glass Vials | Sigma | 854190 | |
Hydrogen Peroxide | Lobachemie | 00182 | 30% Solution, AR Grade |
Labolene | Thermo-Fischer Scientific | Detergent | |
Laser 532 nm | Coherent | Sapphire | |
Laser Cutter | Universal Laser Systems | ILS12.75 | |
Lissamine Rhodamine DOPE | Avanti | 810150 | 1,2-dioleoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphoethanolamine-N-(lissamine rhodamine B sulfonyl) (ammonium salt) |
Methanol | Finar Chemicals | 30932LL025 | |
Microscope | Olympus | IX81 | |
Phosphate Buffer Saline (PBS) | 1X | ||
Plasma Cleaner | Harrick Plasma Inc | PDC-002 | |
POPC | Avanti | 850457 | 1-palmitoyl-2-oleoyl-glycero-3-phosphocholine |
Programmable Syringe Pump | New Era Pump Systems | NE1010 | High Pressure Syringe Pump |
PTFE Caps | Sigma | 27141 | |
PTFE Tubing | Cole-Parmer | WW-06417-21 | Masterflex, 0.022" ID x 0.042" OD |
Sulphuric Acid | SD Fine Chemicals | 98%, AR Grade | |
TIRF Objective | Olympus | UPLAPO100XOHR | |
Vacuum Desiccator | Tarsons | ||
Vortex Mixer | Tarsons |