This method describes a simple and fast strategy for histone proteoform characterization and investigation.
Histones undergo various post-translational modifications (PTMs) such as methylation, acetylation, phosphorylation, acylation, and ubiquitination, which control nucleosome dynamics and determine cell fate. The nucleosome, which is the functional unit of chromatin, comprises DNA, four pairs of histones (H3, H4, H2A, and H2B) making up the globular core, and the linker histone H1, which stabilizes the chromatin structure. The amino (N)-terminal tails of the histones protrude from the globular core domains and undergo distinct PTMs that influence the chromatin landscape. Some evidence suggests that histone PTM homeostasis is crucial for preserving all physiological activities. The deregulation of histone PTMs is the primary cause of abnormal cellular proliferation, invasion, and metastasis. Therefore, developing methods for characterizing histone PTMs is crucial. Here, we describe an effective technique for isolating and analyzing histone isoforms. The method, based on the combination of two orthogonal separations, allows the enrichment of histone isoforms and the following mass spectrometry identification. The technique, originally described by Shechter et al., combines acid-urea polyacrylamide gels (TAU-GEL), which can separate basic histone proteins based on size and charge, and Sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gels (SDS-PAGE), which can separate proteins by molecular weight. The result is a two-dimensional map of histone isoforms, suitable for in-gel digestion followed by mass spectrometry identification and western blot analysis. The result is a two-dimensional map of histone isoforms, suitable for both in-gel digestion followed by mass spectrometry identification and western blot analysis. This proteomic approach is a robust method that allows the enrichment of a single histone isoform and the characterization of new histone PTMs.
Cancer onset, progression, and chemoresistance are related to genetic and epigenetic events, including histone PTMs. Histones undergo a variety of PTMs that regulate chromatin dynamics and dictate cell fate1.
The nucleosome is the functional unit of chromatin and is a molecular complex of DNA and proteins that allows DNA to be packaged into the nucleus. It consists of four pairs of histones (H3, H4, H2A, and H2B) that constitute the nucleosome core, as well as the linker histone H1, which helps stabilize the chromatin structure. The histones amino (N)-terminal tails protrude from their globular core domains and undergo specific post-translational modifications that affect the chromatin landscape2.
So far, at least 23 classes of histone PTMs are known. These PTMs are covalent modifications that mainly consist of methylation, acetylation, phosphorylation, glycosylation, ubiquitylation, SUMOylation, and ADP-ribosylation3. In addition, a tight correlation between epigenome homeostasis and metabolic rewiring has recently been proposed, which explains the exponential growth of the possible number of histones PTMs4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11,12,13. Histone PTMs, deposited, erased, and transduced by modifier enzymes, are named respectively as writers, erasers, and readers. They affect the physical and chemical properties of chromatin structure, impacting gene expression profile, including the expression of tumor suppressor genes and oncogenes14,15,16.
The number of histones proteoforms increases when incorporated into the nucleosome as histone variants. These variants are non-allelic isoforms of canonical histones, and they add complexity by altering the chemical and physical properties of chromatin. In comparison to canonical histones, histone variants have functional domains that undergo unique post-translational modifications or interact with specific chromatin components, impacting the dynamics and stability of the nucleosome17.
In cancer cells, the deregulation of histone PTMs and variants affects gene expression profile, leading to abnormal cellular proliferation, invasion, metastasis, and the activation of drug resistance pathways3,18,19,20. Mutations within histones or chromatin remodeling complexes can alter cell phenotype, contributing to neoplastic transformation. The accumulation of epigenetic alterations, such as histone methylation, is a key factor in activating drug resistance pathways21,22,23. Mutations within the SWI/SNF complex, which consists of 15 subunits encoded by 29 genes, impact over 20% of human cancers across many tumor types. In the past decade, epigenetic-based drug strategies (epi-drugs) have been developed, and many drugs targeting cancer with abnormal histone modification patterns have been approved by the US Food and Drug Administration (FDA)23.
The analysis of histone proteins is quite challenging, making it a demanding area of study. Recently, mass spectrometry methods have become the preferred way for characterizing and studying histone proteoforms. However, the drastic extraction conditions, in combination with the poor solubility of some variants and the high sequence homology, make their analysis challenging.
In the past decade, several mass spectrometry-based methods have been developed for histone profiling and investigation24,25,26,27. In this study, we present a cost-effective and reliable method to create a two-dimensional map of histone proteoforms, which can enhance the chances of discovering new post-translational modifications.
2D TAU electrophoresis combines separation in acidic conditions with SDS PAGE. In the first dimension, the medium's acidic condition gives a net positive charge to basic proteins. Since histones are very basic proteins and have a higher isoelectric point (pH) compared to the medium, they become positively charged and migrate under an electric field. In the second dimension, histones are denatured by SDS and separated based on their molecular weight. The resulting 2D map can be used as a tool to enrich specific proteoforms at single-spot resolution for mass spectrometry analysis and immunological studies28,29. After electrophoresis, 2D TAU spots can be destained, trypsin-digested, and analyzed by mass spectrometry. Alternatively, the 2D TAU map can be blotted onto a nitrocellulose/PVDF filter and investigated by immunostaining27.
In this context, the methods might be strategic to improve the identification and analysis of novel post-translational modifications correlated with metabolic rewiring30,31.
We have further improved the original method by incorporating a sonication step, which is helpful for DNA degradation and improving protein solubility. Additionally, we have prolonged the incubation step for histone extraction, in order to obtain a protein sample with high purity. Moreover, in our protocol, we ran the first dimension at low voltage for a longer duration to achieve a better resolution. The resulting gel was used for investigating canonical histones PTMs and characterizing novel modifications such as glycation10,32.
Overall, we have developed a method for extracting and purifying histones, followed by the resolution of histone proteoforms using a two-dimensional map. The work also includes a procedure for in-gel digestion for mass spectrometry analysis and the steps for two-dimensional western blot analysis.
1. Histone extraction
2. Mini 2D gel triton-acid-urea (TAU) electrophoresis
3. Silver staining 32
4. In-gel digestion
5. 2DTAU western blot
In Figure 1A, it is possible to observe how histone proteins migrate in a 1D gel. This is an important preliminary step to understand the running time of the first dimension. Once the right time of separation is determined, run the second dimension. The 2D map of histone proteoforms shows a distinctive topographic pattern (Figure 1B). Each spot in Figure 1B represents a specific histone type. Observe the exact region of the gel where each histone proteoform can be found. The mass spectrometry identification for each histone proteoform is reported in Perri et al.32. Therefore, each spot in this condition is associated with a specific histone type. The presence of additional spots, alongside the canonical ones, may indicate the existence of novel modifications. Gel images can be acquired using densitometry, and the resulting image can be analyzed using image analysis software.
The reliability of the 2D TAU map is dependent on the spot's rotundity. If the run has been performed correctly, the spots will appear as distinct signals and no horizontal and vertical streaking will be visible. Conversely, impurities in the sample, solutions, and agarose overlay might cause streaks and/or stripes in the gel. The quality of the gel will impact the image digitalization and the following quantitative and qualitative analysis. Moreover, it might influence the success of Western Blot analysis and MS investigations. To verify the reliability of the method, we probed the nitrocellulose membrane of resolved histone proteoforms with the primary antibody Acetylated-Lysine (Ac-K2-100) Rabbit mAb32 (Figure 2). An anti-rabbit HRP secondary antibody was used to detect histone signals. As expected, using a densitometer, it is possible to quantify the peculiar post-translational modification on each histone variant present in the blot.
Figure 1: 1D and 2D TAUgel. (A) Representative image of histones topographic pattern obtained using 1D TAUgel. (B) Representative image of histones topographic pattern obtained using 2D TAUgel. Data identifications are reported by Perri et al. 32. As expected, each spot represents a specific histone proteoform. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 2: Representative 2DTAU Western blot. In the image, it is possible to observe the level of lysine acetylation in each histone proteoform. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Reagents | Concentration: 15% |
40% Acrylamide/Bis | 3.75 |
1.5 M Tris pH 8.8 | 2.5 mL |
MilliQ water | 3.6 mL |
10% SDS | 100 µL |
10% APS | 50 µL |
TEMED | 5 µL |
Table 1: Resolving gel solution composition.
Step | Time |
Fixing 50% methanol / 5% acetic acid | 1 h |
Wash 30% ethanol | 2 x 20 min |
Wash deionized water | 1 x 20 min |
Sensitizer Thiosulfate reagent | 1 min |
Wash deionized water | 3 x 20 s |
Silver Silver nitrate | 30 min |
Wash deionized water | 3 x 1 min |
Development Developer | 25-30 min Note: Develop the gel until the spots are visible (light brown) |
stopping solution | 1 x 10 min |
Wash deionized water | 2 x 5 min |
Wash deionized water | 1 h |
Table 2: Silver staining method.
In the past decade, cancer patient therapy has been revolutionized by identifying various molecular alterations that drive cancer development and progression. The most significant advancement in modern oncology is the development of therapy based on comprehensive molecular analysis. Technological advances in genomics and proteomics have played a crucial role in profiling specific biomarkers for early detection, surveillance, prognosis, and drug monitoring. Proteomics is defined as the analysis of the complete protein complement of a cell, tissue, or organism under a particular condition, and it also includes the study of protein interactions, post-translational modifications, and localization34. A specific area of proteomics is epi-proteomics, which involves the systematic study of histone post-translational modifications. These have been linked to the development and progression of cancer35. The paper outlines a method for identifying specific histone isoforms that contribute to the cellular phenotype.
The critical step of the method is extracting histones because of their poor solubility and high basicity. Its major limitations are the complexity of the 2D map and the low number of variants, which might make the MS/MS analysis difficult.
Overall, the major benefit of this approach is that it can be carried out in any laboratory, and a mini gel apparatus can be owned with the appropriate precautions. In this context, we are confident that this method might aid a large number of scientists, such as those who cannot benefit from a large facility in their institution, to identify novel epi-markers, aiming at improving the knowledge about the epi-proteome. Furthermore, this method can be combined with mass spectrometry, which can be outsourced as a service, to discover novel proteoforms. It can also be used with immunological assays to confirm the changes in a specific post-translational modification for which a commercial antibody is available.
The method has been used to study the typical changes in histone modifications related to the development of breast cancer28 and to examine the modifications of H1 in mouse embryonic stem cells36. Additionally, the method has been successfully employed to measure the level of histone carbonylation37 in rapidly growing fibroblasts and to explore new histone modifications, such as histone glycation and histone MARylation38.
From our perspective, we are confident that this method can be successfully applied for profiling novel histone PTMs, particularly those associated with the abnormal activation of specific metabolic pathways, such as acetylation, malonylation, methylation, lipidation, lactylation, butylation, and others. Ultimately, the method could also serve as a micro-preparative tool for isolating individual proteoforms and may facilitate the analysis of metabolism-linked PTMs, thereby enhancing our understanding of this crucial area of research.
The authors have nothing to disclose.
The work was supported by PRIN2022, DS, CF, and AC were supported by PRIN2022, and MLC was supported by PhD program in Molecular Oncology, UMG PhD program school. The work was also supported by Project PNRR INSIDE CUP: B83C22003920001
1,4-Dithioerythritol | SIGMA- ALDRICH | D8255 | Reagent for maintaining −SH groups in the reduced state; quantitatively reduces disulfides. |
1,5 M Tris-HCL buffer, pH 8.8 | BIO-RAD | 161-0798 | Resolving Gel Buffer |
10x Tris/Glycine/SDS | BIO-RAD | 1610772 | Use this premixed 10x Tris/glycine/SDS running buffer to separate protein samples by SDS-PAGE. |
2-Propanol | SIGMA-ALDRICH | 33539 | 2-Propanol (Isopropanol) is a secondary alcohol. It has been tested as a substitute to fuel for use in various fuel cells. CuO powder dissolved in 2-propanol has been used for the laser ablation assisted synthesis of Cu colloids. Suspension of 2-propanol with Zn(NO3)2 has been employed for the fabrication of titanium dioxide-coated stainless steel (P25-TiO2/SS) photoanode coated with uniformly thick layer of P25-TiO2.This photoanode was used for the electrochemical photocatalytic (ECPC) degradation process. |
30% Acrylamide/Bis Solution | BIO-RAD | 1610158 | 2.6% Crosslinker. Electrophoresis purity reagent |
Acetic Acid Glacial | Carlo Erba Reagennts | 401392 | Acetic acid is an important chemical reagent with many industrial applicatios. |
Acetone | Panreac Applichem | 211007.1214 | Acetone is a solvent, renowned for its versatility in various laboratory, manufacturing, and cleaning applications. |
Acetonitile | VWR | 83640320 | for HPLC LC-MS grade |
Agarose | Invitrogen | 15510-027 | Agarose is a heteropolysaccharide frequently used in molecular biology. |
Ammonium bicarbonate | SIGMA-ALDRICH | A6141 | minimum 99,0% |
Ammonium persulfate | SIGMA-ALDRICH | A3678 | For molecular Biology, For electrophoresis, ≥98% |
Bioruptor plus | Diagenode | B01020001 – B01020002- B01020003 | sonicator |
Dithiothreitol | SIGMA- ALDRICH | D9163-5G | Reducing agent used to reduce disulfide bonds in proteins. |
Dodeca Silver Stain Kit | BIO-RAD | 161-0480 | The Dodeca silver stain kit is easy-to-use for the detection of nonagram levels of proteins in polyacrylamide gels. |
Glycerol | GE – Healthcare Life Sciences | 171325010L | Glycerol is a simple triol compound, it is involved to aid in casting gradient gels, protein stabilizer and storage buffer component. |
Halt Phosphatase Inhibitor | Thermo SCIENTIFIC | 78428 | Thermo Scientific Halt Phosphatase Inhibitor Cocktail preserves the phosphorylation state of proteins during and after cell lysis or tissue protein extraction Single- Use Cocktail (100X). |
Halt Protease Inhibitor | Thermo SCIENTIFIC | 78430 | Thermo Scientific Halt Protease Inhibitor Cocktail (100X) are ready-to-use concentrated stock solutions of protease inhibitors for addition to samples to prevent proteolytic degradation during cell lysis and protein extraction. Single- Use Cocktail (100X). |
Hydrochloric acid | SIGMA-ALDRICH | H1758 | BioReagent, for molecular biology |
Iodoacetamide | SIGMA-ALDRICH | I6125 | ≥99% (NMR), crystalline |
KCl | SIGMA-ALDRICH | P9541 | Potassium chloride, KCl, is generally used in laboratory routines. Its use as a storage buffer for pH electrodes and as a reference solution for conductivity measurements is well established. |
MCF10 cell line | atcc | CRL-10317 | epithelial cell line that was isolated in 1984 from the mammary gland of a White, 36-year-old female with fibrocystic breasts. This cell line was deposited by the Michigan Cancer Foundation. |
MgCl2 | SIGMA-ALDRICH | 208337 | Magnesium chloride is a colorless crystalline solid. |
N,N,N',N'-Tetramethylethylene-diamine | SIGMA-ALDRICH | T9281 | For Electrophoresis, approx. 99% |
Phosphate saline buffer 1X | Corning | 15373631 | 1 X PBS (phosphate buffered saline) is a buffered balanced salt solution used for a variety biological and cell culture applications, such as washing cells before dissociation, transporting cells or tissue, diluting cells for counting, and preparing reagents. |
Potassium hexacyanoferrate | SIGMA-ALDRICH | 60299 | Electron acceptor, employed in systems involving electron transport, |
SDS Solution 20% (w/v) | BIO-RAD | 161-0418 | Sodium dodecyl sulfate. Electrophoresis purity reagent |
Sodium thiosulfate, ReagentPlus 99% | SIGMA- ALDRICH | 21,726-3 | Sodium thiosulfate, ReagentPlus 99% |
Sulfuric acid | SIGMA-ALDRICH | 339741 | Sulfuric Acid, Reagent, is an extremely corrosive acid that comes as yellowy slightly viscous liquid. It is soluble in water and is a diprotic acid. It has very strong corrosive, dehydrating and oxidizing properties as well as being hygroscopic. |
Trichloroacetic acid | SIGMA-ALDRICH | T6399-5G | Trichloroacetic acid (TCA) is used as a reagent for the precipitation of proteins1,2 and nucleic acids3. |
Trifluoroacetic acid | Riedel-de Haën | 34957 | Trifluoroacetic acid |
Triton X-100 | SIGMA- ALDRICH | T9284-1L | Triton X-100 is a nonionic polyoxyethylene surfactant that is most frequently used to extract and solubilize proteins. |
Trypsin from porcine pancreas | SIGMA-ALDRICH | T6567 | Proteomics Grade, BioReagent, Dimethylated |
UREA | SIGMA-ALDRICH | 33247 | Urea is a chaotropic agent and is used for protein denaturation. It disturbs the hydrogen bonds in the secondary, tertiary and quaternary structure of proteins. It can also disturb hydrogen bonding present in DNA secondary structure |
.