The goal of this protocol is to describe a preclinical animal model of Group B Streptococcus (GBS)-induced chorioamnionitis. The study is designed to investigate mechanistic processes, potential causal links with developmental impairments, and finally to develop translational anti-inflammatory placento- and neuro-protective treatments.
Group B Streptococcus (GBS) is one of the most common bacteria isolated during human pregnancy. It is a leading cause of placental infection/inflammation, termed chorioamnionitis. Chorioamnionitis exposes the developing fetus to a high risk of organ injuries, perinatal morbidity, and mortality, as well as life-long neurobehavioral impairments and other non-neurological developmental issues. The two most frequent subtypes of GBS isolates from maternal and fetal tissues are serotypes Ia (13%-23%) and III (25%-53%). Our lab has developed and characterized a rat model of GBS-induced chorioamnionitis to study subsequent impacts on the central nervous system of the developing fetus and to understand underlying mechanistic aspects. This article presents the design as well as uses of the preclinical rat model, which closely reproduces the hallmark of GBS-induced chorioamnionitis in humans. This article aims to help scientists reproduce the experimental design as well as to provide support through examples of troubleshooting. The present model may also contribute to potential discoveries through uncovering causes, mechanisms, and novel therapeutic avenues, which remain unsettled in many developmental impairments arising from chorioamnionitis. Furthermore, the use of this model may be extended to the studies of perinatal non-neurological common and severe morbidities affecting, for instance, the retina, bowel, lung, and kidney. The main interest of this research is in the field of GBS-induced fetal neurodevelopmental impairments such as cerebral palsy (CP), attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD), and autism spectrum disorder (ASD). The rationale supporting this model is presented in this article, followed by procedures and results.
Maternal immune activation (MIA) has been described as one of the most critical independent risk factors for premature birth, fetal death, and lifelong cognitive and behavioral impairments in the progeny1,2,3,4. Much of the existing preclinical research about the role of gestational inflammation on placental and developmental outcomes uses pathogen components, such as lipopolysaccharide (LPS) from E. coli and the synthetic analog of viral double-stranded RNA, polyinosinic: polycytidylic acid (Poly[I: C]), that mimic viral infections. However, even though Group B Streptococcus (GBS) is the most frequent cause of perinatal infection, few animal models have addressed its role in inflammatory mechanisms at play and the outcomes5.
GBS is an encapsulated gram-positive coccus that colonizes the lower genital tract in approximately 15%-30% of pregnant women6. It leads to placental infection/inflammation, termed chorioamnionitis7,8. Of the ten GBS serotypes, the two most frequent serotypes Ia and III are major infectious determinants of injuries in maternofetal tissues9,10. GBS infection has been shown to lead to a higher inflammatory response in fetal blood and placental deficiency, which are highly suspected to be involved in multiple neurodevelopmental disorders such as cerebral palsy (CP), attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD), and autism spectrum disorder (ASD)5,11.
Over the past ten years, we have developed a rat model of GBS-induced chorioamnionitis that leads to various developmental impairments in the offspring12. This preclinical model demonstrates the causal link between GBS-induced placental inflammation and a range of sex-specific neurodevelopmental impairments in the offspring13,14,15. The goal of this article is to provide readers with insight into the design of a preclinical rat model of end-gestational infection and resulting neuro-behavioral impairments in the offspring. The present protocol aims to mimic the clinical reality of GBS-induced chorioamnionitis.
Results from this preclinical model show that end-gestational intra-peritoneal (IP) inoculation (Figure 1) of GBS leads to (i) placental infection and inflammation, fulfilling the diagnostic criteria of chorioamnionitis16; (ii) a massive upregulation of IL-1β and downstream inflammatory molecules from the IL-1-pathway, within the placenta12; (iii) neurodevelopmental impairments in the offspring12; (iv) sex differences in immune responses and subsequent neurobehavioral impairments, such as female offspring presenting adult ADHD-like traits while male offspring present early-onset and long-lasting ASD-like traits; (v) distinct neurobehavioral outcomes in the progeny depending on the GBS serotype used to induce chorioamnionitis14,15. In line with these findings, the main next steps utilizing this model will be to test, firstly, the role of androgen in GBS-induced chorioamnionitis and, secondly, the placental- and neuro-protective role of molecules targeting specific inflammatory pathways, in the hope to bring some of these molecules to the threshold of therapeutic clinical trials.
All experiments were approved by the Research Institute of McGill University Health Centre (RI-MUHC). All experiments were performed according to the Canadian Council on Animal Care.
1. Pregnant Lewis rats
2. Bacterial growth
3. Injection technique
4. Dose determination
5. C-section and tissue collection
IP inoculation of GBS resulted in placental infection
Immunohistochemistry (IHC) (using polyclonal antibodies targeting GBS serotype Ia) staining showed that GBS infection reached the decidual compartment of the placenta. Infection also spread from the decidua to the labyrinth, chorionic plate, and in some instances, to fetuses leading to fetal death (5.8 ± 0.8 in GBS-exposed vs. 9.3 ± 0.6 pups in control (CTL) litters)18. Hence, the litter size was decreased at birth among GBS-exposed fetuses compared to unexposed fetuses18. Intra-litter inconsistencies in terms of placental infection were observed. The GBS infection was self-limited in all dams as well as in newborns, but some dams presented GBS bacteremia/septicemia15. Those developing such dissemination of GBS infection also developed a higher pro-inflammatory cytokine response13. No positive GBS blood culture was detected in pups at P114. Maternal behavior was not impacted by end-gestational infections. There was no mortality in GBS-exposed pups during the postnatal period.
The GBS-induced placental inflammatory response fulfilled the diagnostic criteria of human chorioamnionitis
Interleukin (IL-1β) and polymorphonuclear cells (PMNs) play a major role in anti-GBS host defense15. As expected, at 3, 6, 24, 48, and 72 h post-GBS infection, IL-1β titers in the blood of GBS-exposed dams were higher than in unexposed dams18. A similar IL-1 response was detected in fetal blood and placentas 72 h after injection18. At both 24 h and 48 h post-GBS inoculation, both maternal and fetal compartments of the placenta showed a significant increase of PMN and GBS infiltration compared to controls15. These findings were demonstrated through histology (Figure 4 and Figure 5)15. In summary, these results show that IP inoculation of GBS results in placental infection and induces an innate immune response, which is typical of chorioamnionitis.
Sex-specific innate immune response triggered by GBS
At 72 h post-GBS infection, PMN cell infiltration in the fetal compartment of the placenta was higher in males than in females. The PMN-chemoattractant, CINC-1, also showed a 1.6-fold increase in male placentas compared to litter-matched females. Similarly, there was a significant interaction between sex and treatment for IL-1β detected in the placenta at 72 h post-GBS infection (Figure 6)15. Levels of IL-1β detected in fetal sera correlated positively with those found in maternal circulation (Figure 7)15. No sex effect was observed in other pro-inflammatory cytokines implicated in GBS-induced chorioamnionitis, including IL-18, IL-6, and TNF-α. Altogether, GBS-induced innate immune signaling through the IL-1β, CINC-1, and PMN axis presents a sexually dichotomous profile, with more prominent inflammation in males compared to females12.
Brain injury and neurodevelopmental impairments in male versus female progeny in utero exposed to GBS infection
Enlargement of lateral ventricles of the brains from GBS Ia-exposed males (but not females) was shown through histology at P4014. GBS-exposed forebrains also showed a reduction in thickness of the corpus callosum and the external capsule14. Offspring's social behaviors at P40 were of interest to study as this is a feature of ASD-like behavior, which is suspected to be induced by a combination of genetic and environmental factors, including pathogen-induced maternal immune activation14. The total duration of social interactions was significantly decreased in GBS Ia-exposed males vs CTL males as well as GBS-exposed females14. In the same line male (but not female) offspring presented decreased pre-pulse inhibition (P35), ultrasonic vocalization (P7), and nest-seeking (P9) behaviors, which are other cardinal markers of ASD-like behavior in rodents14. In summary, these results show that gestational exposure to GBS Ia-induced chorioamnionitis plays a key role in the generation of sexually dichotomous, neurodevelopmental abnormalities comparable to human ASD. In contrast, more than males, female offspring with in utero exposure to GBS Ia-induced chorioamnionitis present hyperactivity and disinhibition after puberty and at the adult age, which is reminiscent of ADHD-like behavior in human adult females19. Intra-uterine growth retardation (IUGR), which persisted beyond the adult age, the dysmyelinated white matter of the corpus callosum adjacent to the primary motor cortices, and cerebral-palsy-like motor impairment occurred in newborn pups with in utero exposure to GBS III16. Interestingly, the severity of the IUGR of males exposed in utero to GBS III chorioamnionitis correlated with the intensity of their motor impairments assessed by decreased total distance traveled at P25 measured by the Open field test16. The severity of the decrease in thicknesses of the primary motor (M1) cortices correlated with the decreased density of microglial cells in the corpus callosum of GBS III exposed male rats, but not female rats16.
Figure 1: Intraperitoneal inoculation. Level and location of needle insertion for appropriate GBS IP inoculations of dams. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 2: Processing GBS Bacteria. Materials used for GBS inoculation on G18. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 3: Plating GBS. Serial dilutions of GBS and CHROMID Strepto B agar plates for GBS screening. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 4: PMN cell infiltration within the placenta. PMN cell infiltration in the placenta following GBS infection. Representative images of PMN infiltration in the decidua (a), junctional zone (b), labyrinth (c), and amnion (d) at 72 h post-inoculation. Black triangles show infiltrated PMN cells. Reprinted with permission from reference15. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 5: GBS infection of the placenta. Representative images of immunohistochemical detection of GBS Ia infiltrates in placentas from GBS-infected versus non-infected dams. Reprinted with permission from reference15. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 6: Concentration of IL-1β in placentas at 48 h and 72 h. A linear mixed model was used to compare GBS-infected placentas with CTL placentas, with Sidak's multiple comparisons when the interaction between sex and treatment was significant. **P < 0.01, ***P < 0.001. Number (n) of placentas in the CTL group is n = 5 (48 h) and n = 5 (72 h) per sex and that in the GBS group is n = 4 (48 h) and n = 6 (72 h) per sex. One male (M) and one female (F) placenta were used per litter for analysis. Reprinted with permission from reference15. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 7: Correlation between levels of IL-1β in fetal sera and maternal sera at 72 h post-GBS inoculation. The within-subject correlation between the fetal and maternal levels of IL-1β was analyzed by linear regression. Reprinted with permission from reference15. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Critical steps in the protocol
Several steps of the protocol are critical and require some quality controls. For instance, there is a risk of contamination of the GBS stock by other pathogens. This can be rapidly identified using the appropriate technique of GBS microbial identification such as colony aspect on BHI agar (e.g., size, shape, color), plating in duplicate the β-hemolytic GBS dose on Columbia blood agar with 5% sheep blood medium and on CHROMID Strepto B agar, a selective chromogenic medium for the screening of GBS.
Another issue is that some dams are asymptomatic carriers of GBS. Hence, some accidental infections might theoretically occur in non-GBS inoculated control dams. However, in our hands, GBS staining in the placenta of control animals never detected GBS-induced chorioamnionitis. If this unlikely event were to happen, it would not significantly affect the experimental design we propose. Due to this reason, it was not deemed necessary to use pathogen-free animals.
Protecting infected dams and their offspring from undue stress is important. Any stress added to the infection can induce noxious effects on the experimental subjects. Hence, great attention must be paid to appropriate husbandry, reassuring way of handling animals, protection against background noises, respect of a very quiet environment around delivery and birth, avoidance of mixing animal species in the same room, and other classic measures of prevention of stress routinely used in animal facilities.
Modifications and troubleshooting of the method
Several variations of the above-described protocol might be considered. Lewis rats were used in this protocol. The maternal behavior of rats, compared to mice, is more tolerant to health issues of the progeny, which favored the quality of care of the offspring and resilience of the dam to health issues in the progeny20. However, it might be useful to adapt our experimental design to other rodents such as mice, and to other strains of rats, not only to study interspecies consistency but also to get access to some experimental techniques such as transgenic animals which are more available and cost-effective in mice compared to rats.
To establish the difference between infectious and/or inflammatory effects of GBS-induced chorioamnionitis, inactivated GBS Ia was used instead of alive bacteria12,18. The technique of GBS inactivation has been described earlier12. In another experimental design of GBS inactivation, infected dams were treated with the antibiotic (ampicillin), which is relevant to the treatment used at the bedside in human chorioamnionitis. Also, the ampicillin treatment induced a transient surge of pro-inflammatory response (cytokines release, and PMN infiltration, within the placenta)13. These variations around our original model open novel avenues of research, which remain to be explored to better understand physiopathology and develop a new therapeutic intervention in GBS-induced chorioamnionitis.
Another issue encountered was an over-mortality of infected dams observed sporadically. In our experience, this was sometimes due to an inadequate technique of IP injection (see steps 3.1 and 3.2) affecting vital abdominal organs, or due to direct injection within the vascular bloodstream. Alternatively, some mutations were observed over time in our stock of the GBS Ia strain, creating a drift toward a more aggressive and life-threatening strain. This can be easily suspected in some instances by observing a more rapid in vitro proliferation of the bacteria.
Limitations and significance of the method with respect to existing/alternative methods
There are limitations in this preclinical model of GBS-induced chorioamnionitis. Firstly, it does not accurately reproduce ascending chorioamnionitis (i.e., from the vaginal cavity) caused by GBS in humans. In studies by Randis et al. and Nobel et al., authors describe a novel model of ascending GBS infection in pregnant mice21,22. Such a model offers many advantages, including that it closely mimics human colonization by GBS, minimizes invasive manipulation of dams, and avoids preterm delivery or fetal loss21,22. Rats have more pregnancies than humans; this creates differences in the exposure of the fetus to bacteria based on closeness to the lower genital tract. Secondly, bacteria are inoculated into the peritoneal cavity in this model. This protocol does not replicate most human chorioamnionitis, which is primarily within the uterus, even if the hematogenous route of placental contamination is also described for instance from urinary infection23. Other preclinical models of GBS-induced chorioamnionitis used the intra-vaginal route of inoculation. However, this was associated with intra- and inter-litter variance of GBS load between placentas/fetuses as it depended on location within the uterine cavity. Intra-uterine injections can sometimes produce abscesses due to a focal injection area, making chorioamnionitis unlikely to occur, thereby not accurately mimicking human chorioamnionitis. Furthermore, since the target of injection is so small, a lack of litter reproducibility is likely. Thirdly, other differences exist between rodents and humans. These include pH of the vagina, hormonal cycling, vaginal microbiota, and bacterial adherence between the murine vaginal epithelium and the human vaginal mucosa21, and in the immune response24,25. Regardless, the main objective in designing this model was to mimic GBS-induced chorioamnionitis. This methodology is similar to that of many other investigators who have used IP injections of poly(I: C), LPS, and other infectious components of microorganisms to mimic MIA1,26,27,28,29,30,31. Fourthly, another limitation in the GBS rat model is that placental morphology is different between humans and rodents; for example, the maternofetal interdigitation is villous in humans but not in rats. This may therefore result in species-specific interactions between pathogens and placental cells32. An attractive model is the guinea pig due to similarities to human pregnancy, including comparable progesterone levels, placental structure, sensitivity to pathogens, and length of gestation33. Fifthly, while current studies focus on GBS serotype Ia and III, other serotypes of GBS are also implicated in infection during pregnancy, particularly serotype V. Finally, another limitation of this work is that dams experiencing GBS infection might develop changes in their maternal behaviors toward their pups. As a result of the infection, GBS-positive dams experience reduced weight gain which is indicative of sickness. The use of foster mothers might be proposed but it also induces biases.
Importance and potential applications of the method in specific research areas
There is a lack of studies in the literature addressing the nature of the infectious/inflammatory mechanisms, which underpin GBS-induced chorioamnionitis and their roles in developmental impairments. In humans, the hallmark of acute chorioamnionitis is a massive infiltration of PMNs34. PMNs play an important role in the production of IL-1β, which triggers the production of chemokines that further drive infiltration of PMNs in GBS-infected organs35. The maternal IL-1β response observed upon GBS infection likely resulted in the recruitment of PMN cells within the decidua and labyrinth, possibly originating from both maternal and fetal blood. Thus, determining the role of IL-1 is an important avenue of research in GBS-induced chorioamnionitis, which might be tested using a GBS model.
Using the established end-gestational GBS model developed in our lab, it was determined that there was an in utero sex-specific innate immune response. The exaggerated male innate immune response observed may be connected to a sex-specific anti-inflammatory response. Clinical studies have shown that there is a higher concentration of IL-1 receptor antagonist (IL-1Ra) in female amniotic fluid compared to males36,37. Since the androgen receptor (AR) is present in all innate immune cells involved in chorioamnionitis, these conclusions could be a result of the influence of sex hormones on the production of IL-1 by immune cells38,39. Thus, determining the role of testosterone on the GBS-induced placental and fetal response would be of interest. Another avenue of further research would be to induce the IL-1 blockade by IL-1Ra to uncover the role that IL-1 plays in GBS-induced maternal immune activation.
The perinatal period is extremely important for brain development and thus the dysregulation of cytokines during this sensitive period can result in CP, learning impairments, ADHD, ASD, and other developmental impairments40,41. Using the model of GBS-induced chorioamnionitis, the progeny displayed sexually dichotomous behavioral impairments: ASD-like, cerebral palsy-like traits, forebrain white matter tract alterations in males versus ADHD-like behavior in females. This is in keeping with the male sex bias, which is documented in multiple human perinatal morbidities, including ASD, CP, and ADHD. In conclusion, these results provide further clarity into the inflammatory processes that contribute to the skewed sex ratio of neurobehavioral impairments after placental infections.
The authors have nothing to disclose.
This study was supported by the Research Institute of the McGill University Health Centre (RI-MUHC), Canadian Institutes of Health Research (CIHR). This study was made possible by the following funding agencies, institutions, and foundations: Canadian Institute of Health Research (CIHR), Foundation of Stars, Fonds de Recherche Québec-Sciences (FRQS), McGill University, and Sherbrooke University. Many thanks to Dr. Claire Poyart, University Denis Diderot (Paris VII), France, and Dr. Mariela Segura, University de Montréal, Canada for the generous gifts of GBS.
5 mL sterile tube | BD Biosciences | ||
50 ml falcon tubes | Thermo Fisher | 339652 | |
Blade or scalpel | BD Medical | 371716 | |
Brain Heart Infusion Broth | Criterion (Hardy diagnostics) | C5141 | |
CHROMID Strepto B agar plate | BioMerieux, Saint-Laurent | 43461 | |
Columbia blood agar 5 % with sheep blood medium | Thermo Scientific | R01215 | |
Forward primer | 5' – TAC AGC CTG AGG ACA TAT TA3' | Sigma | |
Insulin syringe | Becton, Dickinson and Co(BD) | 324702 | |
Lewis rats | Charles River Laboratories | ||
Methylbutan | Sigma Aldrich | M32631 | |
Microtainer blood collection tubes | Becton, Dickinson and Co(BD) | 365965 | |
Reverse primer | 5' – GCA CTT TAA CCC TTC GAT GA -3' | Sigma | |
Serological Pipettes 1 ML | Thermo Fisher | 170353N | |
Serological Pipettes 10 ML | Thermo Fisher | 170356N | |
Serological Pipettes 25 ML | Thermo Fisher | 170357N | |
Serological Pipettes 5 ML | Thermo Fisher | 170355N | |
Superfrost Plus Micro Slide, Premium | VWR | CA48311-703 |
.